The Great Torque Tool Runoff

For those of us with carbon fibre bicycles or components, we are always worried about over tightening the bolts as this will damage the carbon fibre. An expensive mistake as I learned a few years back with a carbon seat post which was trashed when I misread the reading on my torque wrench.  I recently received my new Silca torque took from a Kickstarter campaign that I supported so I thought it was a good time to do a comparison of a few tools. Clockwise from top left: Topeak Torque 5Birzman M-Torque, Silca T-Ratchet and Ti-Torque, and then my ‘standard’ which is a precision dial adjustment torque wrench.

PIC_20161217_191907

To test them I used my aero-bars which have a 7 NM torqued bolt—which meant I could safety test the ‘usability’ and consistency of the different units against my standard. 

PIC_20161217_191412

It is important to note that the Topeak and Birzman are torque “limiting” tools. This means that they are pre-set to 5 NM of torque and as you tighten them and reach that torque there is a ‘click’. By comparison, the Silca is a continuous torque tool which uses a titanium ‘spring’. With this, you tighten to the desired torque and release. It also means that you CANNOT use the Silca to loosen bolts or you will damage the spring.  The Silca comes with a nice kit, particularly the T-Ratchet which is a micro-ratchet allowing you to put in/remove bolts easily.

PIC_20161217_192018

Testing was simple. I tightened the bolt to 5 NM and then tested each of the other three units to see if they would over torque the bolt, as well as how easy they were to use. Conclusions.

Ease of Use: Topeak Torque 5. Hands down the easiest tool to use. Simply insert, turn, and wait for the click. It is a massive improvement over the earlier Richey/Giant tool that I’ve used in the past as the longer body makes it easier to control. Only downside is that you still need a multi-tool as this will not go beyond 5 NM. Matched the standard.

Most Useful: The Birzman M-Torque. This essentially replaces your multi-tool as you can keep on tightening after you have hit the limiting torque. The disadvantage is that it is not that easy to use. The design is brilliant. There is a circular button which you put your thumb over, and then have your index finger on the diagonally opposite corner—making sure you don’t touch it anywhere else. The button clicks when you get to the desired torque. Perhaps my hands are too small, but I found it hard to use.  Matched the standard.

image

Best Design—But Most Difficult/Dangerous to Use: The Silca T-ratchet is an incredible design. I love the small ratchet tool as it is great for quickly inserting bolts. It is also by far the lightest of all the tools. The disadvantage? The graduated scale is too close together so there is a great potential to damage your components. Admittedly, I have bad eye sight and wear glasses, but in my workshop it was really hard to ensure that I was at 5 and not higher. Had they been able to calibrate the spring so that the scale was wider this would be perfect.

PIC_20161217_191917

What to use? I’m going to keep on playing with the Birzman and see if I can master its use, but for an infallible and simple tool the Topeak wins hands down.

Advertisements

One response to “The Great Torque Tool Runoff

  1. park tools also have a great workshop tool.. Pretty solid and stable, with adjustments for different sizes on different road and triathlon bicycles. you should look into it as i use it on my triathlon bike

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s